Blogs & News

Anonymous Critic

MASH: No more

November 22, 2006

Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3

20061122_mash_320x240.jpg

This may be the wrong time to say this, due to the untimely death of Robert Altman, but I can’t watch any more episodes of M*A*S*H.

It’s a show that still holds the honor of having the most-watched series finale of all time. But here’s a little known rumor that I’m going to continue to spread about the Nielsen families. We hear a lot of speculation in the TV circuit about the ratings system’s flaws back in the day.

And "MASH" is supposed to be the prime example.

In a time when television was just beginning to explore it’s political side, or “TV that means something” – "MASH" was doing a show about war. And though many of the Neilsen families weren’t watching it, (because let’s be honest, it’s just not that funny) a lot of them were writing into their "watching journals" that they were. Hence the huge ratings. This is, let’s be clear, just a rumor we’ve heard a few times. And there’s no real way to be sure. But boy, that makes sense.

READ MORE > >

Comments

Edgeoforever wrote:

Mash has been the sanity zone on TV - as I avoided the pundits lying about the current war.
Sorry Altman died, I loved his other movies but M.A.S.H was not one of them.
The series though - I watch every night - and always laugh. And never at the straw man examples you gave.
We live in times of an absurd war, when everyone is been afraid to to tell the truth for years. Very few truthful voices on TV on the matter.
Keith Olberman. Comedy Channel and Hawkeye.That's about it.

wasteofbandwidth wrote:

To show how much of a moron you are,
"with a drunken clown-doctor with a clever nickname" really would have been more relevant with "drunken-clown doctor" as more often than not, alcoholism, and it's effects, were shown more than "clown-doctors". (ie: doctors that dressed as clowns) Perhaps you should think about the actual Vietnam War AND it's effetcs. Until thwen, you get an "F" on interpretation.

Wasn't funny? Neither was Cheers. And perhaps Cheers could have benefitted from a few more episodes highlghting the effect of drunk driving. Cliff gets thrown through his mail truck's front window because he's a booze-hound would have made a great episode. TV isn't about reality, it's about entertainment, moron.

PileggiFan wrote:

MASH not funny? Hmmm. When did they start letting aliens from Planet Idiot write columns here?

Karen wrote:

What are you talking about? Mash was one of the very first shows of it's kind. You have to be older than 35 to appreciate the humor. Just because it doesn't have curse words, people like jackass on it, doesn't mean it isn't one of the funniest shows of all time.

Chris M. wrote:

You don't even have to be 35 to appreciate it, I've significantly younger than that and the show's *fantastic.*

Dennis Booth wrote:

I have the complete collection of MASH. It was and still is a funny show, Alda is absolutely brilliant but there is much more to the series than just humour. The pathos and the sheer hell of war is more than ably demonstrated in any number of the series. Might I suggest that as good as Altman was that perhaps a shade of envy and jealousy set in that a spin-off of his successful movie was so tremendously successful. Lets face it for the show to run for so long and to have to many viewers says a great deal. I think also from memory that more people viewed the final episode than any previous show.

Smelly Kelly wrote:

My friend! Looks like you and me are in a very exclusive group. When I was a kid, I *LOVED* TV and would watch just about anything. Anything except "M*A*S*H*" (or "Barney Miller," but that's another post for another time). To me, "M*A*S*H*" was terribly pretentious and self-rightous and self-important and not terribly funny.

And I think it still is. My local FOX affiliate recently used to run it at various times on the weekends and light nights. It came on, and I figured I'd give it a try, since I'm a grown up now. Didn't make no difference. I found it terribly pretentious and self-rightous and not terribly funny.

The only reason I would even thing about watching it is to see Wayne Rogers, because I'm a sucker for cute, curly-headed guys. But then Alan Alda gets on my last nerve, so. . .

helen wrote:

I think the series was a lot funnier than the movie. I didn' care for the movie, but loved the series. I like to watch it every night. Anyone who thinks the people who like the series are morons, is a moron themselves. We all have different tastes and as long as there are people who enjoy the show, it should be aired in sindication.

DL wrote:

MASH is and always will be a classic but it may be difficult for someone in this era of idiot, Jackass, Reality TV numbness. As for the ratings rumor, who cares now. Maybe the same goes for many shows. Not just the one you are targeting. ANd for the truly idiotic, it was the Korean War not Vietnam, dumba**.

greg wrote:

MASH was funny and thought-provoking (although
you didn't know you were thinking) at one time.
But as soon as a political agenda enters the
scripts, it goes flat, they all do. Look at
DESIGNING WOMEN, as soon as we had to hear Linda
Bloodsworth's political views, the show failed.

Indigo810 wrote:

MASH was by far one of wittiest, poinant, heart-wrentching, clever, wonderfully-written and honest TV shows, then and now. I was 7 yrs old when I first started watching it on late-night reruns (along with Mary Tyler Moore and The Odd Couple), grew up to watch the series (it aired at 9pm, Mondays, I think), bawled thru the series finale when I was in HS, and I continue to watch it everytime its on, along with watching it on my DVD collection. In fact, I didn't know of the film until I was in HS--I grew up watching MASH. I appreciate the film also as being incredibly witty. Nothing gets better than MASH...it's timeless humor...

dumbod wrote:

Actually, there were two MASH's. The first had McLean Stevenson and Wayne Rogers. It was funny and somewhat more true to the "Suicide is Painless" soul of the movie. It was TV but, remembering the time frame, it had some edge.

The second MASH became the Alan Alda show; was preachy, predictable (watching Alan Alda do poor Groucho impressions got really old really quickly), unsubtle and not funny. It was the "personification" (showifcation?) of dumbing down. Too bad.

Linda wrote:

Writing that MASH was not (is not)funny ranks right up there with saying this Administration knows what they are doing in Iraq? What planet is that guy from?

Luvin'Life wrote:

The examples you give illustrate your superficial point of view. "enter drunken clown doctor" sounds as if there was a new one each week & if Loretta Switt was "mannish" for being outspoken, then I guess her obsession with Frank was her inner homosexual male side trying to get out?

Criticize her character for being too emotionally dependent on a buffoon or something else real when picking on the show, for pete's sake. This show was (at the time) innovative and risk-taking and other shows began delving further into realism because of it.

You don't like war and humor? Blame America's early viewing audiences for having to be spoon fed a realistic view of war in comedic blended doses. But you might want to start with Hogan's heroes, Sgt.Bilko, Gomer Pyle, etc, or even F-troop for that matter.

Unwilling to admit to enjoying our emotionally stunted, head in the sand, racially insensitive, bone-headed early TV shows?

Maybe you should give a show that attempted to move us past that fluff and get us thinking, a break--even if it did get preachy at times.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)






Send to a Friend

E-mail this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):



Anonymous Critic Archive



Warning: include(/var/www/bravo-blogs/newswire/promote_small.html) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /var/www/bravo-blogs/anonymous_critic/other_blogs.shtml on line 1

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening '/var/www/bravo-blogs/newswire/promote_small.html' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/lib/php/includes:/usr/local/php/includes:/usr/local/php4/lib:/usr/local/lib/php') in /var/www/bravo-blogs/anonymous_critic/other_blogs.shtml on line 1

Warning: include(http://www.brilliantbutcancelled.com/includes/promotes/promotes-astrocast-small.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.0 404 Not Found in /var/www/bravo-blogs/anonymous_critic/other_blogs.shtml on line 3

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening 'http://www.brilliantbutcancelled.com/includes/promotes/promotes-astrocast-small.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/lib/php/includes:/usr/local/php/includes:/usr/local/php4/lib:/usr/local/lib/php') in /var/www/bravo-blogs/anonymous_critic/other_blogs.shtml on line 3

Recent Comments

July 25, 2008 at 02:54 PM

Shows "On the Bubble"

Excinkilync: "[url=http://forums.megagames.com/forums/member.php?u=204320]adult free msn passport site vid web[/url]"

July 25, 2008 at 01:38 PM

71 Finales, Previews and Specials in August

Siber: "This website is Great! I will recommend you to all my friends. I found so much useful things here. Thank..."

April 2, 2008 at 12:09 PM

Jericho: Storytelling in a time of Fear-Mongering

Sandra Cole: "I am a fan of the tv show Jericho. I missed the last episode and I cannot get the information..."

March 24, 2008 at 01:22 PM

Top 20 NYC Based Shows

Patrick: "What about Newsradio?! WNYX!"

March 14, 2008 at 09:25 AM

Friday Night Lights

Nancy: "I miss the show so much! I love it! When I missed some of the first season's episodes, I tried..."

March 6, 2008 at 01:32 PM

Friday Night Lights

Gina T: "Friday Night Lights is my FAVORITE show to watch.....I have missed it so much! I have my DVR to automatically..."